The Robert Noyce Teacher Scholarship Program

NSF
NSF
  • Home
  • The Program
    • NSF Noyce Program Solicitation
    • Consider Becoming a NSF Noyce Principal Investigator
    • Consider Becoming a NSF Noyce Reviewer
    • Become a Noyce Scholar or Teacher Leader
      • Noyce Scholar Profiles
      • Noyce Alumni Profiles
    • Voices From the Field Videos
  • Project Locator
    • Select from Map
    • Advanced Search
    • Submit Information
  • In the News
    • In the News
  • Meetings
    • 2023 Noyce Summit
    • 2022 Noyce Summit
    • 2021 Noyce Summer Events
    • 2020 Virtual Noyce Summit
    • Archived Noyce Summit Materials
    • Noyce Regional Networks
  • Resources
    • Noyce Track 4 Research Book
    • Proposal Preparation Toolkit
    • Noyce Project Videos
    • Noyce Summit Abstract Catalogs
    • Reports
    • Toolkits
    • ARISE Research Community
  • Contact

The Iterative Development of Consolidation After an Inquiry-Based Lesson

  • Year 2023
  • NSF Award #2050659
  • Registration Master Teaching Fellow

  • First Name William
  • Last Name McKinney

  • Discipline Mathematics
  • Institution Engineering & Science University Magnet School

Abstract

This year my team of math teachers began designing inquiry-based Calculus lessons inspired by thin-slice activities as described in Chapter 9 of Building Thinking Classrooms in Mathematics. These tasks ask students to examine patterns to make sense of structure and discover concepts and rules. Consequently, they empower students to take the lead on consolidation. However, with the elimination of direct instruction and notes, students do not have any resources with which to study or recall the learning that occurred in past classes.
We thus set out to determine what tools best empower students to identify their own learning, to summarize that learning into student-friendly language, and to provide students resources they can return to later.

We sought to enhance the sense of community in our math classes by improving communication amongst students, deemphasizing competition, encouraging collaboration and the sharing of ideas, and highlighting the contributions of each student.

Through this process we identified key preferences of students for the consolidation process, including having a graphic organizer to structure their thinking that included a place to record their conclusions and practice questions that directly tie into those conclusions. They also prefer to complete the conclusions section in groups, checking those conclusions with a gallery walk, and then coming together as a class afterward to ask clarifying questions. The following class students prefer to review solutions to select practice questions before moving on to the next activity.

Improving the consolidation phase lead to equitable outcomes by directly addressing students’ own math identities. Through this process, students were more willing to share ideas with others and demonstrated greater confidence when they did so.

What’s New

  • 2025 Noyce Summit
  • 2024 Noyce Summit
  • Proposal Preparation Webinars
  • Noyce PI Peer Webinars
  • Noyce Regional Networks
  • Noyce by the Numbers: 20 Years of Noyce
  • Frequently Asked Questions for the Robert Noyce Teacher Scholarship Program
  • Become a Noyce Scholar or Teacher Leader
  • Consider Becoming a NSF Noyce Reviewer
  • Consider Becoming a NSF Noyce Principal Investigator
  • Noyce Alumni: Where Are They Now?

Check out our ARISE website for research & opportunities!

Checking In

NSF

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) under Grant Numbers DUE-2041597 and DUE-1548986. Any opinions, findings, interpretations, conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of its authors and do not represent the views of the AAAS Board of Directors, the Council of AAAS, AAAS’ membership or the National Science Foundation.

AAAS

The World's Largest General Scientific Society

  • About Noyce Program
  • AAAS ISEED
  • Subscribe to ARISE
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
© 2026 American Association for the Advancement of Science